Sherlock Holmes Chapter One: Sacrificial Lamb, Police Station - walkthrough Sherlock Holmes Chapter One guide, walkthrough

On this page of the Sherlock Holmes Chapter One game guide you will find a walkthrough of the mission Sacrificial Lamb. We described tasks that take place at the police station. By completing this quest you can earn an achievement - Vengeance of the Lamb.

Last update: 13 December 2021

On this page of the Sherlock Holmes Chapter One game guide, you will find a walkthrough of a story case called Sacrificial Lamb. We've described the quest taking place at the Police Station. There you'll talk to all the suspects and decide who the killer was. For completing the quest, you will get an achievement called "Vengeance of the Lamb".

• Cell
• Archives
• Evidence
• Vogel
• Pinchetti
• Matista
• Manchios
• Deduction
• Last conversations
• Ending

Cell

This mission will begin in a cell to which you were sent after the party at the residence. When the cop is done with you, it's time to check the letters on the interrogation table. After reading them, you can come to the firsts conclusions about the case.

It is necessary to match:

1. Santos Pinchetti informed the police,
2. Pinchetti is a majordomo.

Archives

There's a cop in the archives in charge of the case. Talk to him and present him with the evidence you've already gathered. He promises you the case file on Sherlock's mother in exchange for help.

Evidence

After talking to the cop, it's time to gather the next evidence. To make the man give it to you, you need to mention the ticket. That way you will get 3 drawers with contents.

In the drawers, you will find:

1. syringes,
2. letters,
3. notebooks,
4. keys,
5. a handkerchief,
6. a ring,
7. a book,
8. keys,
9. a medallion.

Vogel

It's time to go to all the detainees. Vogel is not a suspect. You need to talk to him to present the evidence you've already gathered. He will not tell you much, return to him after questioning the others and deducting the facts in the Mind Palace.

Pinchetti

In cell number 7, you'll find the first suspect. Santos Pinchetti has a drawer on a desk that you have to check. In there are keys and letters.

After a short conversation, take a closer look at the man. You need to inspect:

1. a collar,
2. a shirt,
3. a vest,
4. shoes.

The correct conclusion about Santos is - Has financial difficulties.

After inspecting the man, it's time to ask him about all the evidence you've already gathered.

Matista

In cell number 6, you'll meet a woman named Matista. She's another suspect.

After a short conversation, take a closer look at the woman. You need to inspect:

1. bruises on the neck,
2. cuts on the arms,
3. bitten nails,
4. burn marks,
5. a tattoo on the chest.

The correct conclusion about the woman is - Punishes herself for the past.

After inspecting the woman, ask her about all the evidence you've collected.

Manchios

You'll find Manchios in cell 5. After a short conversation, you need to take a closer look at him. You should attention pay attention to the following:

1. makeup on the cheeks,
2. red spots behind the ears,
3. washed hands,
4. polished shoes.

The correct conclusion about the man is - Hides his age. After that, you have to ask him about everything you know.

Deduction

Time to enter the Mind Palace and connect all the already acquired clues. Start with:

1. The murderer cleaned theirself;
2. Kurt Manchios is scrupulously clean.

The next connection is:

1. The murderer cleaned theirself;
2. Blood on Pinchetti's shoe.

Then connect:

1. Fabio was assaulted in a nearby room;
2. Matista has fresh bruises.

The next facts that you have to match are:

1. Pinchetti is a majordomo.
2. Manchios mocked Pinchetti.

There are many connections to make and the next should be:

1. Santos Pinchetti informed the police,
2. Blood on Pinchetti's shoe.

The next ones are about the woman who is one of the suspects. Select:

1. The Power of Love;
2. Matista trusted in the occult over Fabio.

And other facts about Matista:

1. Matista's activity at the party;
2. Matista has fresh bruises.

Another clues concerns feelings between men:

1. Angry letter from Fabio,
2. Kurt Manchios gave Fabio expensive gifts

The last two clues you need to connect are:

1. Manchios has a washing routine
2. Kurt Manchios is scrupulously clean.

Last conversations

Time for another meeting with an old friend. Once the facts are combined, you'll have to visit all the detainees again. Make sure you've talked to everyone and raised all the subjects.

Ending

After gathering all the evidence and putting all the facts together in the Mind Palace, it's time to conclude the case. There are three options:

1. Santos Pinchetti,
2. Matista,
3. Kurt Manchios.

No one pleads guilty. It's up to you to decide who you'll convict. This does not affect the further plot. Sherlock will get his mother's files he cares about anyway.

However, the important thing is to choose the most severe punishment, which is hanging. You will get an achievement - Vengeance of the Lamb.

When you decide who is guilty, go to them and tell them about your investigation. Everyone will deny it. After that, go back to the police officer in the archives and share the final verdict. This will end the case.