Sherlock Holmes Chapter One: Everyone's a Critic trophy - how to get? Sherlock Holmes Chapter One guide, walkthrough
This Sherlock Holmes Chapter One guide page describes how to unlock the Everyone's a Critic trophy.
Last update: 06 December 2021
This page of the trophy guide to Sherlock Holmes Chapter One features a detailed description of the Everyone's a Critic trophy. You'll get the trophy when you find all three books in the Bazookaeology trilogy.
Searching for these books is one o the tasks you'll receive form Jon. When you complete this task, your relationship will improve. For more information about your friendship with Jon, see a separate page in our guide - Jon - does the relationship with him affect the ending.
Book 1
You can access the Gilden Residence by using the key you took from the coat by the river. We've described this plot point on the page Gilded cage - elephant escape.
As soon as you approach the stairs, Sherlock go to Imogen's room on his own. The woman will be surprised at how you got into her home, but in no way will she be negative towards you. She'll be happy to tell you what she heard and answer any questions.
We described the conversation with Imogen on a separate page of the guide Gilded Cage - Gilden Residence.
After interviewing the woman, you need to search a cabinet. It's on the right side of the bed, between a white, ornate dresser and a similar vanity.
Here you will find the first book in the Bazookaeology trilogy. It's on a pile of clothes, right under the green skirt. All you have to do is pick it up.
Book 2
The next book is in the workshop. It's located south of the harbor. We marked it on the map above, so you can easily get there. It's really close to the hotel. If you got to that area, you'll be able to get to the workshop within a minute.
You don't need a key or a special invitation to the workshop. There's a warehouse on the right side of the building that you need to enter.
You'll find the second book in the Bazookaeology trilogy in the corner, between the wooden crates.
Again, all you have to do is pick it up, so that Jon can note that you found it.
Book 3
The excavations are located in the northeast part of Old City. You will get to them only after completing the appropriate tasks. We've described this part of the story on the page Gilded cage - getting a job.
When you go down the stairs, you'll see the tents full of vases. The book is between them.
It's the third book in the Bazookaeology trilogy. Picking it up will grant you the Everyone's a Critic trophy.