Chapter 3: Thank you for shopping at Save Lots! - Mystery in the barn | Episode II: Starved for Help The Walking Dead Guide
Last update: 11 May 2016
Regardless of the decision you have taken, you and Danny will come back to the farm. Once you've returned, Danny will comment on what happened to Jolene, and then you'll have a short conversation with Brenda. Your answer does not matter.
Again, there are several optional conversations waiting. To make a good start, you can once again open the low Gate behind Lee to talk with Brenda. The "We ran into some trouble out there." option will take you to the next question, but none of your answers here will be important. Go right till you get to Danny. Ask questions one after the other - the "You really like that gun." will lead to a question. Regardless of what you'll answer Danny will notice your suspicion anyway.
Now go in the opposite direction, to the background of the screen, to the barn. Use the wooden Gate to open it and then go to the right, to the gazebo. Again, you will be able to talk to Lilly. You can tell her what happened to Jolene (depending on whether you or Danny shot her, there will be "I shot a woman" or "Danny shot someone." options, and Lilly will remember that). The rest of the answers do not matter, nor do the questions you can ask Lilly. After that go left until you get to the barn door. Open the Barn Door to go inside.
Inside you can look at the Cow and have a few conversations. If you speak with Duck, another conversation will develop. It will refer to the answer you gave Clementine in the first episode, while you were getting to sleep in the barn. Give the hat to Clementine, and then answer her question about whether you will have children. You can also talk with Andy, ask him questions one after another. You aren't able to talk to Katjaa.
Go right. Along the way, you can open the Stall Door, but you won't find anything interesting in any of them. Instead, examine the Door at the back of the barn and use it. After a while, Kenny will come to you. After a brief conversation he will ask you a question - if you choose "You're being stupid." you'll make him very upset ("Kenny didn't like that."). The other answers do not matter.
Take a look at the lock, and, above all, at one of the Screws on the left. After a while, Andy will come up to you and ask what you're doing. You can choose one of the following four responses:
10. "Can I help you folks with something?"
(1): Kenny heard a noise. | You made an excuse. |
(2): Just checking out the barn. | You made an excuse. |
(3): What's behind the door? | You questioned Andy directly. |
(4): ... | Kenny covered for you. |
Andy will "ask" you to not hang around this door. Of course, Lee and Kenny's plan is to do exactly the opposite.
You can talk with Kenny in the barn, but it will not result in anything new. Also, trying to tell Andy to get back to Danny won't be successful - Andy will come back as soon as you try to do something about the locked door. Therefore, go left and use the Barn Door to go outside. You can talk to Lilly, if you want (there will be some new conversation topics). Most of all, however, use the wooden Gate to get through and open the Toolbox on the carpenter's table. Pull out the Multitool and then use the orange Generator on the left.
In order to get rid of Andy you must do several things. First, push the Power Switch of the generator in the upper right corner to turn it off. Next, use the Multi-Tool on the yellow Panel. Finally, use the Multi-Tool on the Belt, which Lee will hide. You can also talk with Brenda to interrupt her chat with Larry (there will be a new conversation topic). To do so, simply open the Gate. First of all, however, go back to the barn.
Go to the locked Door in the barn. It's pointless to talk to Kenny, and the task of searching the closed room will be yours to do. In addition, if you didn't give the hat to Clementine earlier, Lee will do it now. You'll hear the dinner bell. Everyone will run to the house, including Kenny, who will promise to come up with an excuse for you. It is worth mentioning that at this point you might as well get out of the barn through the Barn Door and go straight to have dinner. But there is another, much more interesting option ...
If you want to see what's inside, take a look at the Door and then use the multitool on each of the four Screws on the left side of the lock. Next Lee will open the door and then an unpleasant sight will meet your and his eyes...
After a while, Andy will catch you red-handed and ask if you have not heard the dinner bell. You can lie to Andy by selecting the "I found the door open like that." option, or ask bluntly why there is so much blood in the room. Still, it doesn't matter what you pick. Now, you'll go with Andy to have dinner.