Other deductions (wrong) | The Fate of Black Peter

Neligan Is Guilty

Required Conclusions:

1. Stolen valuable papers;
2. Retrieving the notebook;
3. Neligan's motive;
4. Harmless flirting;
5. Unexplained presence;
6. Hurtley's innocence;
7. Lucky throw;
8. Pouch proves visit.
9. Stolen valuable papers;
10. Retrieving the notebook;
11. Neligan's motive;
12. Desperate jealousy;
13. Unexplained presence;
14. Hurtley's motive
15. Feat of strength;
16. Pouch proves visit.

Hurtley Is Guilty

Required Conclusions:

• Stolen valuable papers;
• Looking for papers;
• Neligan's innocence;
• Desperate jealousy;
• Unexplained presence;
• Hurtley's motive;
• Lucky throw;
• Pouch proves visit.

Two Murderers (later you decide which one of them is the initiator)

Required Conclusions:

1. Stolen valuable papers;
2. Retrieving the notebook;
3. Neligan's motive;
4. Harmless flirting;
5. Unexplained presence;
6. Hurtley's innocence;
7. Lucky throw;
8. Pouch proves visit.
9. Stolen valuable papers;
10. Retrieving the notebook;
11. Neligan's motive;
12. Desperate jealousy;
13. Unexplained presence;
14. Hurtley's motive
15. Feat of strength;
16. Pouch proves visit.

Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments

September 30, 2014

Rate It!

• Overview
• Guide