Chapter 4 - Fractured | Episode 5 - Same Stitch Villain Joker Batman: The Enemy Within Guide

Last update: 07 May 2018

In the fourth chapter (Fractured) of the fifth episode of Batman: The Telltale Series - The Enemy Within you will take part in a game prepared by Joker. You will begin as Bruce and you will be trapped in a moving trolley. You will soon reach a room with Selina and Joker. Joker will leave the room and you will be talking with Selina. The dialogue looks different depending on the choices you've made at the end of episode three:

If you have blamed Catwoman:

Dialogue option

I thought you'd escape.

I shouldn't have done that.

I was right not to trust you.

...

If you took the blame

Dialogue option

You've lied before.

Pretty big gamble.

I believe you.

...

The game prepared by Joker is divided into three stages:

1. Room #1 - how to get the key?
2. Room #2 - a puzzle with graves.
3. Room #3 - a dinner with Joker and Harley.

Room #1

After the conversation, you need to find a way to acquire the key hidden in an under-voltage cage. In order to do that, collect the Riddler Cane shown in the above screenshot. Afterwards, select the key and use the Use Cane option. You need to decide whether you take the key ([Take the key] option) or pass it to Selina ([Pass it to Selina] option). The choice won't affect the course of action, but it will have an impact on the relationship between Bruce and Selina - the first choice will definitely worsen and the second will improve it. After the decision you need to press the buttons popping up on the screen.

You now need to go through a tunnel - head straight ahead until you reach the next room.

Your first task in the second room is to dig through a dirt pile shown in the above screenshot. There you will find a box with a heart. Collecting the heart will cause you to discover a number of cards with images of different people.

You need to match the person from the grave to the one (according to Joker) who killed him/her. Use the cards you've just acquired for the task. Starting from the left side, the graves and cards need to be set in the following order:

1. Lucius Fox - Batman (Bruce will also be counted as a correct choice)
2. Thomas Wayne - Joe Chill
3. Riddler - this grave needs to be left empty.
4. Martha Wayne - Thomas Wayne
5. John Doe - Bruce (Batman will also be counted as a correct choice)

You will suddenly hear someone in a nearby coffin. After opening, it will turn out that Tiffany was inside. A card with the image of Tiffany will also be inside of the coffin. The woman will admit that she's the Riddler's killer. Selina will attack Tiffany:

Dialogue option

This is what Joker wants.

Riddler killed her father.

[Restrain Selina]

...

Just before entering the last room, Tiffany will ask Bruce for a talk once all of this is over:

Dialogue option

You better believe it.

I don't want to hear it.

Let's survive this first.

...

Room #3

An unusual dinner awaits you. First things first, Joker will talk to Bruce:

Dialogue option

This is just sad.

I love dinner parties.

Enough with the theatrics.

...

Now Harley will want to feed Bruce:

Dialogue option

[Spit it out]

[Eat the steak]

I'm not hungry.

...

Alfred will then enter the room. You will need to pick one of the cookies, but this does not have any impact on the future events. After a short while a bomb with a deadly poison will be placed on the table:

Dialogue option

Looks delicious.

Still lying to Harley?

Gordon will find the others.

...

Regardless of your choice, Joker will stab Bruce's leg with a knife:

Dialogue option

[Headbutt]

[Play along]

The choice does not matter - the knife will fly under Tiffany's feet. Another "game" will begin:

Dialogue option

I did it to protect you.

[Lower a finger]

[Stare him down]

Dialogue option

I never meant to hurt you, John.

[Lower a finger]

[Stare him down]

Tiffany will kick the knife towards Bruce and will make a ruckus for you to pick it up. Joker will suggest that Bruce is the one who murdered John:

Dialogue option

I'm sorry.

John's not dead.

Good riddance.

...

Now Harley will try to initiate the bomb:

Dialogue option

Joker sold you out.

Please stop her, John!

Regardless of your choice (but remember - you need to make a choice before the time runs out), Harley will attack Joker and you will have some time to disarm the bomb. A fight with Joker and Harley will initiate - press the appropriate buttons.

Joker will run out of the room and Bruce will follow him:

Dialogue option

You broke my heart, John.

I need to put you away.

You're nothing special.

...

Regardless of your choice, another fight will begin. Joker will lose consciousness and Bruce will save him. The men will begin talking:

Dialogue option

So you can face justice.

Your life has value.

I'm not like you.

...

Joker will ask if the men ever had a good time together:

1. Yeah...we did.
2. I wish we'd never meet.

The answer affects the relationship with Joker and the ending scene. The first choice causes Joker to forgive Batman, the second will make Joker hate Batman.

The action will move to the ambulance. Bruce will be talking with Waller:

Dialogue option

You better not betray me.

I don't believe you.

I appreciate that.

...

Afterwards, you can talk about various people or simply say goodbye. Selecting specific people leads to the following dialogues:

Gordon:

Dialogue option

He never wears a badge again.

He deserves to be honored.

He should probably retire.

...

Avesta:

Dialogue option

She can come work for me.

Give her a second chance.

Don't lay a finger on her.

...

Selina:

Dialogue option

Do what you want with her.

Clear her criminal record.

Keep her out of Gotham.

...

Now the action will move to the roof of the building and Tiffany will want to leave the city. Depending on the choices made in episode three, the following dialogue will initiate:

You did not tell Tiffany that Bruce Wayne is Batman

In this case Tiffany will want to leave Gotham with Waller.

Dialogue option

We have to be better than them.

You sound like Waller.

There's always a line.

...

Regardless of your choice, Tiffany will head towards the helicopter and Batman will give her his last words:

Dialogue option

Watch your back with Waller.

Don't forget who you are.

I will bring you to justice.

...

You told Tiffany that Bruce Wayne is Batman

In this case Tiffany will want to leave Gotham with the help of her costume:

Dialogue option

I wish I didn't know.

You should be afraid.

You could have told me.

...

Dialogue option

You're only human.

Nothing justifies murder.

At the end of the conversation you need to make an important decision:

1. You need a mentor.
2. You need to face justice.

The first option will improve your relationship with Tiffany and will make Batman her teacher. The second one will definitely worsen the relationship and will turn Tiffany into a criminal.

Now Bruce will head to his estate to learn that Alfred wants to leave Batman:

Dialogue option

Just take a vacation.

You can't leave me.

Then just leave.

...

Note - selecting Then Just Leave will end the conversation and Alfred will leave the estate immediately, without stating the reason for doing so.

Dialogue option

So just be my butler.

You said you weren't a coward.

I can't do this without you.

...

Alfred will start talking about Joker:

Dialogue option

You encouraged this plan.

Yeah, and it worked

That was a mistake.

...

Alfred will suggest that Batman creates enemies for himself:

Dialogue option

You must be drunk.

The good outweighs the bad.

There's evil without Batman.

...

Dialogue option

That's the cost of war.

Stop whining, Alfred.

We can fix that.

...

Alfred will suggest that his health problems come from Bruce:

Dialogue option

Don't put that on me.

Alfred, I'm so sorry.

I'm that bad, huh?

...

Dialogue option

I'm not turning into my father.

You can't really believe that.

Give me a break.

...

Dialogue option

You did the best you could.

I'm nothing without you.

We failed each other.

...

A signal calling Batman will appear in the sky and you will need to make a decision:

1. Give up Batman.
2. Give up Alfred.

The Give up Batman option will cause Bruce to abandon his Batman identity and Alfred will stay in the estate. The Give p Alfred option will cause Alfred to permanently disappear from Bruce's life.

At the end of the conversation you will witness the summary of the gameplay and a final scene with Joker at the Arkham prison. You've just completed Batman: The Telltale Series - The Enemy Within.