Trial by Tavern Pirates of Caribbean 2 Guide
Last update: 11 May 2016
It's high time to get the crew together, the basis of which is Mr Gibbs. Protect him from enemy attacks, lighting candles on each table while doing so to find another Map Piece. After the battle, Gibbs'll tell you where to find Cotton and Marty Dwarf. Cotton's behind the door, getting strangled by a pirate for an inappropriate remark by his parrot. After defeating the pirate, take the key and exit the room through the second door.
You'll end up in another room, where apart from a group of pirates is Marty the Dwarf, hanging from the ceiling like a growth-impaired pinata. Cut up a beam to make a catwalk by which you'll reach the rope keeping the wee man aloft. Now you need to return while El Grande keeps screwing with you.
He isn't much of a challenge, though, because it's sufficient to knock over the barrels next to him, burying him in a heap of woodchips. Return to the room where you began and defeat the last group of pirates, thus ending the mission.