Broken Sword: Shadow of the Templars - Reforged

The main pros of the game

• Nostalgia and Charm: Many players express a deep emotional connection to the original game, highlighting its charm, memorable characters, and engaging storytelling.
• Visual and Audio Upgrades: The remaster features stunning 4K graphics and improved audio, enhancing the overall experience while retaining the original's spirit.
• Gameplay Improvements: The game includes quality-of-life features such as a hint system, a diary for tracking progress, and an updated user interface, making it more accessible for modern players.
• Faithfulness to Original: The remaster stays true to the original game, with options to switch between the new and old graphics, preserving the essence of the classic adventure.
• Clever Puzzles and Humor: Players appreciate the cleverness of the puzzles and the humor present throughout the game, contributing to an enjoyable experience.

The main cons of the game

• Audio Quality Issues: Several reviews mention that the remastered audio, particularly the voice acting, can sound muffled or distorted, detracting from the overall experience.
• Character Development Concerns: Some players feel that the remaster does not adequately develop certain characters, particularly Nico, who is perceived as sidelined compared to her role in the original.
• Pacing and Dialogue Length: There are complaints about the pacing of the game, with some dialogues being excessively long or repetitive, which can lead to frustration.
• Missing Content from Director's Cut: Players note the absence of additional scenes and content from the Director's Cut, which could have enriched the experience.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Old Cinematics: Players expressed a desire to have the option to switch to the original cinematics, which were not included in the remaster.
• Improved Character Interaction: Some users wished for more dynamic interactions and development for characters, especially Nico, who they felt was underutilized in the remaster.
• Enhanced Dialogue Options: A few reviews mentioned that having more varied dialogue choices or additional character insights would have improved the gameplay experience.
• Customizable Gameplay Mechanics: There were suggestions for more customizable options, such as adjusting walking speed or having a more traditional inventory system.

Summary

• Overall, "Broken Sword - Shadow of the Templars: Reforged" is celebrated for its nostalgic value and modern enhancements, while also facing criticism for certain audio issues and the omission of content from previous versions.

Summary generated on: October 30, 2025