Pentiment

The main pros of the game

• Art and Visual Style: The game features stunning artwork that mimics medieval manuscripts, creating a unique and immersive visual experience. Users praise the art direction as superb and fitting for the historical context.
• Deep Storytelling: Players appreciate the rich narrative that explores themes of art, life, loss, and societal issues. The writing is highlighted as one of the game's strongest assets, with many finding it thought-provoking and emotionally impactful.
• Historical Accuracy: The game is noted for its well-researched historical setting, effectively transporting players to the Renaissance period and immersing them in the culture and politics of the time.
• Character Development: Users find the characters to be believable and relatable, with well-developed backgrounds that enhance the story.
• Replayability: Many reviews mention the game's replay value due to the branching choices that affect the narrative, encouraging multiple playthroughs to explore different outcomes.

The main cons of the game

• Pacing Issues: Some players felt that certain sections, particularly Act 3, were drawn out and lacked the pacing of the earlier parts of the game. There are mentions of tedious walking and limited fast-travel options that can disrupt the flow of gameplay.
• Opaque Choices: Criticism is directed at the dialogue and choice mechanics, with some players feeling that many choices are unclear and lead to missing information or clues. The sense of consequence can sometimes feel unsatisfying if players feel they cannot make informed decisions.
• Limited Gameplay Mechanics: Some users noted that the game leans heavily on dialogue and lacks more traditional gameplay elements, such as puzzles or combat, which may not appeal to all players.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• Fast-Travel System: Many users expressed a desire for a fast-travel option to ease navigation around the town and alleviate the tedium of backtracking.
• More Complex Gameplay Mechanics: Some players wished for more interactive elements beyond dialogue, such as puzzles or investigative gameplay that would enhance the detective aspect of the story.
• Improved Dialogue Tracking: A few users mentioned that not all dialogue choices or important notes are recorded in the journal, which can lead to confusion and difficulty in keeping track of the narrative.

Summary

• Overall, Pentiment is highly regarded for its artistic and narrative achievements, though it has its share of pacing and gameplay mechanics that some players found lacking.

Summary generated on: November 25, 2024