Moonlighter

The main pros of the game

• Unique Concept: The blend of dungeon crawling and shopkeeping is praised as a clever twist, offering a fresh take on traditional RPG mechanics.
• Engaging Gameplay Loop: Many players enjoy the cycle of exploring dungeons to gather loot and then selling it in the shop, which can be satisfying and addictive.
• Visual and Audio Appeal: The pixel art style and soundtrack are frequently highlighted as charming and well-executed, contributing positively to the overall atmosphere of the game.
• Cute Graphics: The game's aesthetic is generally well-received, with players appreciating the detailed pixel art and animations.
• Good Story Elements: While some reviews mention the story as lacking depth, others find it intriguing and enjoyable, particularly the mystery behind the dungeons.
• Decent Replayability: Several players mention the potential for replayability, especially with the New Game+ mode and the DLC content.

The main cons of the game

• Repetitive Gameplay: Many users feel that the gameplay loop becomes monotonous over time, with dungeons and shop management lacking sufficient variety to keep players engaged long-term.
• Combat Issues: Combat is often described as clunky and simplistic, with limitations on movement and attack directions leading to frustration during battles.
• Bugs and Technical Issues: Some players report persistent bugs, including control mapping problems, crashes, and issues with the game's mechanics not functioning as intended.
• Shallow Shop Mechanics: Although the shop management aspect is seen as a highlight, some players feel it lacks depth and becomes tedious, especially with the pricing system.
• Weak NPC and Story Development: Many reviews criticize the lack of meaningful character interactions and a compelling narrative, leading to a feeling of emptiness in the game's world.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to users

• More Diverse Combat Mechanics: Players express a desire for more complex combat options, such as diagonal attacks and a greater variety of weapon types with unique playstyles.
• Improved Shop Management: Users suggest adding more depth to the shopkeeping aspect, such as haggling mechanics, better customer interactions, and a more dynamic pricing system.
• Expanded Story and Character Development: Many reviews call for a richer narrative and more engaging characters to enhance the overall experience.
• Quality of Life Improvements: Suggestions include better inventory management, improved control schemes, and fixes for bugs that hinder gameplay.
• Increased Variety in Dungeons: Players wish for more diverse dungeon designs and enemy types to reduce the feeling of repetitiveness.

Summary

• Overall, while Moonlighter is appreciated for its unique concept and charming presentation, it suffers from repetitive gameplay, combat issues, and a lack of depth in both its mechanics and narrative. Many users recommend it as a decent experience, especially on sale, but feel it has room for improvement in a potential sequel.

Summary generated on: October 29, 2025